Archive for the ‘strategic planning’ Category

Feature Un-creep: simplification at a price…

Wednesday, June 18th, 2008

I personally believe our world, especially with so many feature rich products, is getting more complex every day. So, when I hear about simplifying products by removing features, I certainly applaud the action. However, there is a right way and a wrong way of managing features, especially when these features are already been introduced to the field and are in use by your customers.

Today, Netflix announced a removal of a key feature (at least it is key to me): multiple profiles per account. This valuable feature allows us to maintain several queues, one for each member of our household. For whatever the reason, Netflix has decided to remove this feature, and their FAQ is below. Note that Netflix is not providing any explanation, or an alternative to allow for an easy transition.

Jeff Lash of How To Be A Good Product Manager has a well written article on how to address feature removal from your product: Do not be afraid to remove features. Looking at Twitter traffic on this topic, Netflix product manager should be reading Jeff’s blog and revisiting this decision.

Should features be removed, and products be simplified? Absolutely! However, before one goes crazy over removing existing features, there needs to be a cost/benefit analysis and a good plan to handle the migration issues.

We will be eliminating Profiles, the feature that allowed you to set up separate DVD Queues under one account.
When? Profiles will be eliminated on September 1, 2008.
Why? While it may be disappointing to see this feature go away, this change will help us to continue to improve the Netflix website for all our customers.
Do I need to do anything? Consider moving all DVD titles in your Profiles Queues to your main account Queue. To do so, log-in and visit this page
How will this impact my account? On September 1, 2008:

  • All DVDs currently at home or in transit will be associated with the main account Queue
  • All Profiles rental history will be added into the main account rental history
  • Your additional Profile Queues will be eliminated. If you would like to keep a copy of each
  • Profile Queue we recommend that you print them out
  • Prior to Profiles going away, we will also email you a copy of your Profile Queues
  • Profiles movie ratings and Profiles Friends connections will no longer be available
  • You will not be able to transfer your Profiles data to a separate new account
  • You will be able to set a maturity filter on the main account

Technorati Tags: ,

Build Your Toolkit for Big Picture Thinking

Tuesday, June 3rd, 2008

P5265172The only winning move is not to play” is what WOPR concluded after playing endless drawn games of tic-tac-toe against itself in the movie WarGames. By recognizing the simple cause and effect relationship and learning that sometimes there are no winners, WOPR demonstrated its system thinking, its big picture thinking thereby saving the world.

While the traditional form of analysis focuses on taking apart the individual pieces of the whole to be studied, systems thinking focuses on the whole itself: interactions and interdependencies that takes place between what is being studied and the system it is part of. By expanding the view of the system, more interactions and interdependencies can be identified and analyzed. This expanded view could result in a different conclusion than anticipated through traditional forms of analysis, especially when the system is complex with numerous interactions, internal or external.

Perhaps the importance of systems thinking is best seen in nature. There are numerous case studies of introducing non-native species to new regions for one purpose or another. The Cane toad was introduced to Australia to control sugar cane pests, but instead are now declared as an invasive species in Australia, and are a serious threat to native biodiversity. Along the same lines, Scotch Broom was brought to Pacific Northwest to be used as a garden ornamental. Unfortunately, this bush has bloomed out of control and is now considered an invasive specie in Washington and other states.

Just like the environment, your firm is a complex organism and a living system. As with any system, you need to understand and manage the internal and external interactions and interdependencies to be successful. As I mentioned before in Innovation Process: 3 Things You Can Count On, innovation is an effect in economy and society. To avoid being referred to as an invasive species, you need to incorporate systems thinking, big picture perspective, into your innovation process. How you internally manage your innovation process, how you handle the interactions and interdependencies between your idea generation, strategic planning, resource allocation, competency development and more is just as important for your success. By managing your innovation as a system, internally and externally, you increase the chances of your success.

Below are some tools to help you sharpen your systems thinking. I would love to hear about your tools, and what works for you and your team.

  • Apply the 5 Whys: As painful as it is at times, I do enjoy the Why? questions that my son asks. Asking Why? helps one to move from the immediate symptom to cover the underlying problem, and thereby identify potential resolutions to the issue at hand. Just make sure in the process, you are focusing on facts and not opinions, as your goal is to identify potential actions that you can take. Opinions, finger pointing and such are just explanations that do not lend themselves to solutions. If you do happen to get an explanation, ask again Why else could it be? Each Why? question will take you to a different perspective, different context and expand your system further, opening up new possibilities and potentials.
  • Use scenario planning and stories: Write stories about the potential futures of your innovation. Then use these stories to capture relationships, interactions and interdependencies between various parts to build the view of the whole system. As you build your story, focus on the type of relationships: supportive, limiting, negative, unintended consequences, … Each of these could then feed into your risk management process, your assumption validation and other parts of your innovation management cycle as appropriate.
  • Leverage the power of diversity: In order to uncover hidden relationships and capture the impact of interdependencies you need a diverse team of experts, skills, experiences and perspectives, i.e. a cross-functional team. Bear in mind that as your scenarios and stories expand, so should your team, including potentially suppliers, partners, customers, analysts, … Be flexible with your team structure and be open to signs when you need to reevaluate its membership.
  • Stimulate your creativity: I enjoy shuffling through Roger von Oech’s Innovative Whack Pack. Regardless of which card I pick, it offers a new insight and wisdom that I need to incorporate into my thinking.
  • Compile a portfolio of analysis tools: Porter’s 5 Forces,life cycle analysis tools, cause-and-effect diagrams, TRIZ, value chain analysis and others can help bring a systems perspective to your thinking.
  • Improve your collaboration and change management skills: Systems thinking is about interactions and interdependencies, and how things behave within the whole, internally and externally. It is about recognizing these interactions and changing or managing them accordingly. So, sharpen your collaboration and change management skills to improve your overall effectiveness.

Finally, establish regular checkpoints. As I mentioned before, we are all part of a complex organism and a living system. As you launch your innovation, you will need to continuously monitor and examine the system and analyze if its behaving as expected. If the results are not what you anticipated, then review and adjust. In a way, it is all an experiment.

Technorati Tags: ,

You are not in Kansas any more

Tuesday, May 13th, 2008

I realize that times have changed… However, I did not internalized the amount of change until my neighbor’s 14-year-old said “I love everything wheat!” And it is not just her; my 10-year-old prefers whole wheat over Wonder Bread. I might be living in a community where there is more sensitivity towards environmental, social and health consciousness. However, I bet there are more communities around the world such as ours. And, those are not the only trends that are shifting. You are probably wondering, what does this have to do with innovation or technology management? Let’s break these trends down; jump in with your own observations and insights.

Going green and ethical consciousness

These days, it seems like every other ad in a magazine is about a firm’s greenness and their new environmentally friendly products or processes. Though the ads might be a fad, the growth of environmental and social consciousness is certainly not. Our new generation is observing the negative impact we have had on our environment, on earth’s natural resources and overall society first hand. That consciousness and society’s learnings are here to stay.

My son recently shared his view on space travel: “We have to find a new planet to colonize, as the human race will be extinct given what we have done to the environment.” I hope it is not as black and white as he sees it.

Let’s not forget ethical consciousness. The Internet, always-connected technologies and social networks have significantly increased the degree of transparency firms once had. With that, consumers are more knowledgeable and demand more from your firm. MIT Sloan Management Review recently published a study on Does Being Ethical Pay? (may require subscription.) The study shows that consumers are willing to pay a slight premium for ethically made goods, and would buy unethically made products only at a steep discounts. The Women of The Buyer’s Army is taking activism to the next level as highlighted in the Ode Magazine. Their mission is to raise shoppers’ awareness on how various products are made.

Your mission, if you decide to accept it, is to incorporate green technologies, environmental and ethical consciousness into your organization’s DNA. Right now your customers are demanding it, and tomorrow your workforce will be joining them too.

Talent management

I can’t help but share my observation on the hypocrisy of some of the CEOs out there, in this case Mark Hurd… Anyone that is plugged into the US business news is aware of CEOs’ concerns on dwindling US tech talent. Though I haven’t seen a study, I wouldn’t be surprised to see a cause-effect relationship between early US outsourcing trends to current US graduates in the technology field. However, the part that really bothers me is when a CEO complains about dwindling US tech talent on one breath, and then reduce his US workforce in large numbers in another breath.

So, let’s focus on the real issue at hand. It is NOT that the US doesn’t have talent, it is either not the right talent or not at the right price. Given that, along with accelerated technology shifts and US visa procedures, your talent management strategy has become even more relevant.

In search for a meaning

Maybe the generations are in crisis, or finally we are learning there is more to life than just work. Either way, as average life expectancy increases, so does the need for that life to be more meaningful and purposeful at every aspect of our lives. I should know, as I am one in search of meaning.

As a manager, you might already be experiencing these shifts in your workforce. Changes that have been taking place just from the perspective of technology alone have been amazing, mainly driven by kids that never experienced a world without the Internet, have no clue what a floppy drive looks like or why would anyone want to use such a thing in the first place :) Where the communication is driven by text messaging, instant messaging, emails and MySpace. But even more so, these kids are interested in knowing the purpose, understanding their impact and ensuring a world that is healthy and happy. At the same time, you might be dealing with Generation-Xers that are going through their own career shifts to find that purpose and meaning.

These personal shifts create an interesting challenge for managers: how do you motivate and reward your employees? How do you create growth opportunities that are aligned with their own purposes? How do you ensure the meaning they are looking for matches yours? And, how do you keep those employees?

Our opportunities are global, so are our problems

Globalization is here to stay. No doubt, it has fueled the growth of many firms and improved the lives of many. Unfortunately, it is also highlighting the ever increasing divide between the rich and the poor. (Superclass: The Global Power Elite and the World They Are Making) Lets not forget terrorism, global warming or outbreak of a contagious disease.

As Albert Einstein pointed out “We can’t solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them.” We need to increase our global reach by building virtual teams around the world. So far this activity has been mainly fueled by firms driven to reduce operational costs. However, we need to shift towards building cultural and social awareness of global communities, and bring that to our product and technology planning activities.

Finally, NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) doesn’t have a relevance in today’s global world. We can’t pretend that just because something doesn’t immediately impact us, we don’t have to care about it. The Story of Stuff highlights in a fun way how everything we do is connected. As consumers we are becoming more aware of how our purchasing decisions are shaping the world we live in. As businesses, we need to take to heart the concepts of: sustainability, zero waste, clean production, renewable energy and a more fulfilling purpose that fuels meaning for all.

Technorati Tags: , ,

What is your strategic agility quotient?

Monday, April 21st, 2008

turbulent watersIt was the best of times… It was the worst of times… No worries, not when we have strategic agility.

Just as strategy’s roots come from the military with Sun Tzu, the foundations of strategic agility are thanks to Napoleon. By incorporating mobility and flexibility (corps d’armée system) combined with strong communication channels (communication backbone of marshals), Napoleon revolutionized the war strategies of his time. He recognized time as the key strategic element for his success, and gained a competitive advantage by identifying ways to dynamically organize and structure his attacks based on the latest information from the battlefront: a classic example of marrying strategic planning with strategic agility.

I don’t need to point out that our business environment has changed. For some, it might even feel a bit like a battlefront. Every day it is increasingly competitive, with an abundance of information available instantly to everyone, where constantly evolving technologies accelerate the commoditization cycle, not to mention we may be at the brink of an economic depression. With that, every strategic plan has the opportunity to become obsolete overnight, along with what was once your competitive advantage and differentiation. As they say, never a dull moment.

How well and how fast you predict, foresee, adjust, adapt and exploit opportunities in this ever changing environment defines your strategic agility quotient. With that, strategic agility is not just a nice to have. It should be embedded into your culture, your business processes and organization, and you should make it a key core competency and capability to enable continuous value creation for your company.

To foster strategic agility, you need to invest in many facets of your organization.

  • Management by Objective (MBO): Originally rooted in HP’s management philosophy, MBOs are a great way to align your workforce to the ever-changing needs of your organization.
  • Change management: Your efficiency and effectiveness at mastering change initiatives and handling uncertainty will improve your speed of execution and the flexibility of your organization.
  • Communication backbone: Everyone in your organization needs to understand your business and the context for its success. Through this, they can understand the key triggers to watch, to act upon and more importantly their role for making it happen.
  • Organizational learning: Your culture not only needs to embrace new and different, but also learn from past experiences.
  • Organizational processes and structure: Without a well understood set of processes, new information and knowledge will be lost within the organization. Without an organizational structure that can effectively act on new information and knowledge (prioritization of projects, resources, …), one would be left wishing that the information was never observed.
  • Organizational talent: With your HR team, you need to grow and recruit the needed talent and experience to execute for the future.
  • Environmental scanning: Build in habits and provide tools for your organization to look for future trends. But don’t stop there; encourage communication and incorporation of your findings into future plans and activities.
  • Ecosystem capabilities: You need to extend beyond your organization, to your ecosystem, and build capabilities and a communication backbone for faster response: customer relationship management, supply chain, distribution chain, manufacturing, IT, …
  • Maintain a healthy balance: As with everything, you need to maintain a balanced view between adaptiveness, responsiveness, speed, cost, quality, functionality, brand and customer care.

Strategic Agility PyramidThough strategic agility is a 2-word phrase, building the capability and skills to be strategically agile is more complex. Think of it as a pyramid of capabilities that build on each other, extending beyond your organization’s boundaries. You can utilize this framework to assess your strategic agility. Does your organization and your ecosystem have the intent, the focus towards scanning the horizon and beyond, and to what degree and depth? Do you have the right behaviors to support the intention: avoidance of analysis paralysis, creative analysis, systems thinking, the curiosity to explore and understand? Does your organization and ecosystem extend beyond now to understand new patterns formulating on the horizon, and work collectively to decode the hidden messages? Does your culture welcome new ideas and thoughts at every level? Do you have the processes and structures to make the necessary adjustments and strategic course corrections efficiently and effectively?

Strategic agility is not for everyone, at least not to the same degree. But, recognize that globalization and the speed of change is requiring every industry to embed some aspect of strategic agility into its core in order to survive, even if your sole differentiation is based on operational excellence. So, get to know thyself. Analyze your risk profile, communicate your key boundaries for decision making (hurdle rate, % of customers impacted, resources impacted, ..) and define your key change triggers that your organization must be aware of (new technology, new entrant, shifts in the economy, customer trends, …). Whatever your solution, make sure you are not the frog slowly being brought to a boil

Technorati Tags: ,

Valuing Your Intangible Assets

Thursday, January 31st, 2008

Stapled
Whether we you call it a knowledge-based, idea-based or innovation-driven economy, our firms’ value is more and more driven by our intangible assets. Dr. Robert Shapiro captures this quite eloquently in NDN’s Globalization report, “The Idea-Based Economy and Globalization: The Real Foundations of American Prosperity in the 21st Century.”

This shift is evident in the way U.S. and international investors value America’s public companies. In 1984, the market value of the physical assets of the top 150 U.S. public companies – their “book value” – accounted for 75 percent of the total value of their stocks. A firm was worth nearly what its plant, equipment and real estate could be sold for. By 2004, the book value of the top 150 U.S. corporations accounted for 36 percent of the total value of their shares. Nearly two-thirds of the value of large companies now comes from what they know and the ideas and relationships they own.

Intangible assets include things that are created through time and effort: trade secrets, copyrights, patents, trademarks, source code, know-how, organizational competencies (technologies, databases, culture, capacity for innovation), business processes , company brand, customer loyalty, and not to forget your skilled and trained workforce, i.e. human capital, all contribute to your intangible asset portfolio. Though these are not physical assets that you can see and touch, they can positively effect your bottom-line and the valuation of your firm. Here are some examples:

  • Famous brands: Lexus, McDonalds, …
  • Coco-Cola’s formula: Merchandise 7X
  • Famous logos: Apple, Google, BMW, Nike, …
  • Amazon’s customer review database, Google’s search database
  • Trademarks: Kleenex, iPod, Trinitron, …
  • IBM’s patent database

As important as these assets are, in most cases, management of them are an afterthought. Just like anything else, intangible assets require active management to support, to build and to grow in order to maximize their value while keeping the overall cost down. At the same time, for a variety of reasons, it is difficult to properly manage these valuable intangibles.

  • Challenges of putting together an effective measurement system to track the performance of the intangible assets.
  • Not spending adequate time to understand your core business, its key performance drivers and how they are linked to your intangible assets. But don’t stop there: learn to how to legally protect them.
  • Only focusing on your intellectual property, and not properly analyzing/including your source code, know-how, business processes, workforce skills/expertise, …
  • Neglecting to put together a risk management plan for your intangible asset portfolio to defend as well as advance your leadership position.
  • Solely focusing on defensive moves while forgetting to find ways to nurture and grow your intangibles.
  • Intangible assets may not have direct tangible impact, and very likely complement other intangible assets, such as the case with workforce training in software quality that eventually improves revenues through increased customer satisfaction.
  • Treating your intangible asset analysis as a one time activity, and not managing them as part of your strategic business cycle.

To manage your intangible assets, start with identifying them and determining how they are linked to the success of your strategy and your competitiveness. Perhaps tools such as the cause-and-effect diagram can help narrow down the field while keeping it meaningful, relevant and long-term focused. Balanced Score Card performance metrics can also help to incorporate your intangible assets with your strategy.

Next, put in place a tracking and measurement system to monitor the progress of your intangible assets. Since it can be challenging to put together an effective system, keep it simple and start small. As I mentioned before, make sure your metrics are clear, actionable, support business objectives, and based on data and facts. Finally, build internal awareness for your most valuable intangible assets.

Technorati Tags:

To quit or not to quit: The Dip

Thursday, January 24th, 2008

There are many books that discuss success and how to think and be successful… There are many business books that highlight the importance of opportunity cost (and sunk cost) evaluation in strategic planning… But I know of only one book that merges the two, and redefines success with the idea of strategic quitting.

Seth Godin’s book The Dip: A Little Book That Teaches You When to Quit (and When to Stick) is short and effective. It certainly made me question the wisdom of “Never give up, never surrender!” In many ways, I followed Seth’s logic when I left Amazon.com after 5 months of employment. Quitting is an emotional process, otherwise my decision would have come 2 months earlier!

Seth’s book doesn’t offer a recipe for determining if something is worthwhile to quit. That is a process of self-reflection where you ask yourself: will it/I be remarkable, will it/I be best in the world, or in my case “is this what I want to be known for?” You have to determine those questions for yourself, based on your definition of success.

Strategic quitting is key to aligning yourself towards success, but making sure not to quit too early while in The Dip is also Seth’s message. Yes, getting through The Dip is hard, and that is the point: “The Dip creates scarcity, scarcity creates value.” And, value is created when you lean into the Dip, where you push harder and change the rules. Not when you just chug along…

Quit the wrong stuff.
Stick with the right stuff.
Have the guts to do one or the other.

PS. Seth referred to The Magic of Thinking Big as influencing his thoughts about success. I haven’t read it yet, but it has received good reviews. So, I am adding it to my book list.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Natural evolution of your organization

Friday, November 23rd, 2007

“We cannot direct the wind,
but we can adjust the sails”
— Contemporary Western Proverb

Your firm is a living organism, a complex system. As with all living systems, it self-maintains, self-renews and evolves. The firms that recognize themselves as a living organism, a learning organization are aware of their environment, their place in the ecosystem and the shifts that are occurring. This awareness and sensitivity to internal and external changes gives them the flexibility to adjust and adapt.

Adapt or die” is a common phrase that highlights the importance of survival for firms. As firms adapt and evolve, the organization determines and selects the traits necessary for the survival and through its culture continuously reinforces it. This continuous process of adaptation and evolution further ensures the success and survival of the successive generation.

The life-cycle refers to our knowledge and generalization of living systems, the principles and laws that govern life from birth till death. As businesses, we also go through our life-cycle stages. As always, these are guidelines and not definite steps. As with my son that skipped the crawling stage and went to straight to walking, firms can also skip stages. Here are the common stages of a business life-cycle:

  • Seed: Similar to a plant life-cycle, the seed stage represents the germination of a compelling concept and the push for finding the first set of customers to validate the idea. The firm’s main challenge is market acceptance, and managing resources and time effectively.
  • Startup: This stage is characterized as customer acceptance, where the focus shifts to obtaining new customers and delivering on the product’s promise. Usually at this stage, the firm has enough customers, are able to keep them satisfied and the focus is shifting from survival to managing revenues and expenses. The firms’ main challenge is to have checks and balances to ensure they are on track, and managing the burn rate. This is where you don’t want to run out of money…
  • Growth: Congratulations, you have proven the idea, showed the market validity and are now acquiring many more new customers. The growth stage is a milestone that marks the validation of the idea, which also means increased competition. If the firm is focused on growth, it will strive for operational excellence, proper scaling of the product and the business, and will look at ways to expand into new businesses, markets and customers.
  • Decline: This stage is usually marked by the reduced revenue and profitability. At this stage, there may be a crisis that calls for action and renewal. Or, the organization might be the frog in a pot of cold water, slowly being boiled, not realizing the situation they are in. All focus is now on managing negative cash flow and costs.
  • Exit: The exit stage is all about closing the doors whether due to bankruptcy, selling the business, acquisition by someone, … This process mainly includes proper valuation of the company. There maybe psychological and financial impact that should be managed.

Just like a child growing up, each stage is a change, requiring different nurturing and focus areas for its survival. Yet, basics are needed for survival at every stage: basic management skills, basic financial knowhow, basic marketing competencies. In addition, there are also other factors to consider:

  • Clarity on what you are and what you are not. This is important for your internal decision making, for your customers and your brand image. This continuous adjustment, explicit commitment and mutual adjustment from everyone is needed to achieve results.
  • Know how you compete. Many new firms excel because they stress customer service and flexibility over what established firms can offer. This coupled with focus on high-quality products, flexibility in responding to customer needs and product customization gives them a boost in the market over competition.
  • Innovate while managing your core business. It is too easy to put all your eggs in one basket or over commit yourself. Innovation and technology strategies correlated with growth, but need to be managed.
  • Understand other life-cycles in motion, such as those of your customers. Where they are in their adoption curve drives their purchasing behavior and risk profile.

Technorati Tags: ,

Know thyself: Corner stone of your strategic plans

Monday, November 12th, 2007

Strategic planning is all about the future: where you are going over the next 3+ years, how you plan to get there and how you know when you arrive to your destination. However, your success at your strategic planning all depends on how well you know yourself, and your starting point.

Here are few key areas where you should build a good foundation and understanding in order to achieve success at your strategic plans. It is a good starting point, but not all inclusive. Please add to this list with your experience and insights.

Know yourself
This is all about self-examination and being introspective. It is about recognizing your strengths and weaknesses, understanding your distinctive competencies and realizing your competitive advantage. This process requires you to be true to yourself about who you are, so you can chart a course for who you want to become.

Know your customer
You want to understand your customer better than your customer understands herself. What keeps them up at night; what they don’t foresee today, but will need tomorrow; what motivates them to buy and turns them off; what makes them successful; why their customers prefer them to others; how are they profitable … This is where you are wishing for a mind-meld approach to getting to know your customer. :) In the end, you want to become a specialist in your customer’s businesses. It will help you understand their articulated needs, but also help you innovate for the unarticulated opportunities.

Know your competitor
You need to understand your competitors and your industry in order to play the game. What are the strengths and weaknesses of your competitors? Why are your customers choosing your competitors’ products? What is the layout of the industry structure; how is the ecosystem playing out; what are the trends; … These will help you to identify new opportunities and potential threats.

Know your data
What do you need to insure a sound decision making process? What key performance indicators do you need to benchmark and watch for? Always remember the saying: garbage in - garbage out.

Apply differentiation
There is a subtle yet important difference between being different and differentiating yourself. You don’t just want to be different. In everything you do, you want to offer significant value over your competitors. You want that value to shine through your brand image where your customers, current and future, can clearly recognize it.

Create your safe haven
We are living in a global world where competition is everywhere and customer loyalty is in demand more than ever. Recognize the challenge, and figure out how to create high entry barriers to protect yourself using your strengths. Aside from patents, look to build exceptional customer relationships, alliances and partnerships.

Know your resources
There are always more things we want to do than would fit into the time and resources available. But, that is no excuse to spread your resources too thin. Multi-tasking, frequent context switching will kill the productivity of your team. Instead, prioritize and stay flexible.

Be agile and adapt
In a way, everything is in a constant flux and all things change. So, be alert, stay in control and watch for shifts in the marketplace and in your customers. Recognize the changes, be agile and adapt accordingly.

Minimize your dependence
No doubt we can’t do it all ourselves and we need help. At the same time, recognize your dependencies and work to minimize them. This could be anything from your one customer, a product, partnerships or alliances.

Technorati Tags: , ,

Should I build or Should I buy? and the Myths

Sunday, September 30th, 2007

Today, technology/product choices and development partners are everywhere. This, coupled with collaborative development tools, makes it possible to have a workforce worldwide. Or, you can Google your technical requirements, and probably find a handful of vendors that already built something close to what you want. So, how do you decide when to build or when to buy?

The answer should be simple, right? You do a cost/benefit analysis of buy vs. build, and you follow its recommendation. Yet, there are many variables that affect our decision, and some of these are myths that need to be recognized and dealt with appropriately.

Myth #1 — We have a fact-based decision making process

We like to believe our decisions are driven by logic and data. Yet, our emotions and instincts play into our decision making process more than we care to admit. Just think back to your personal experiences of buying a car. I remember walking out of a dealer because of the lack of chemistry and trust I felt towards the sales-person. This doesn’t mean you should ignore your intuition and your gut feelings. Quite the contrary, you need to incorporate that into the process and use it to further investigate areas that seem too good to be true.

Myth #2 — We can find exactly what we need

We live in a world where the choices are limitless, right? Unfortunately, the buying process is all about making compromises: price, scalability, maintainability, dependency, flexibility, control, support, functionality, time-to-market, availability, usability, integration, … Just look at iPhone customers and what drives them to unlock their phones regardless of the risk: instant messaging, GPS, voice recorder, eBook reader, cheap roaming, … These are all valid features that one would want on their smart phone. ☺

Myth #3 — Our organization’s culture is irrelevant to our decision making process

Quite the contrary! Your organization’s culture and your leadership is everything when it comes to build vs. buy decisions. NIH (Not Invented Here) syndrome is a classic influencer, which usually is followed by the we will loose control argument. Again, these all are valid concerns that need careful consideration. To be successful, you need to bring the team along, consider their concerns and put an action plan in place to deal with the risks. Oh the other hand, if your team is already feeling overwhelmed, asking them to take on another development effort will likely to backfire.

Myth #4 — Buying is not creative/innovative

This is another take on the Myth #3 and the organization’s culture. You need different strengths and competencies to be good at buying. Your customers expect you to deliver a unified solution that clearly solves their business problems. Your marketing team expects you to continue to deliver on your brand image. Your support team needs a supportable and maintainable product. So, obviously buying is more than just throwing things together and expecting them to work well, there is considerable effort involved.

Myth #5 — Building is cheaper than buying

After all, you are already paying for the engineering hours, right? But, what about the opportunity cost? Or, how about the peanut butter approach of spreading your resources too thin? We tend to think about building as a one-time event, without considering the cost of deployment, support, maintenance or scalability. In my experience, obsolescing anything is an emotional process that takes precious time. So, make sure you consider the full picture and not just the one-time engineering costs.

Myth #6 — We can build it faster/better than integrating

This may be a valid argument. But again, just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should. On the surface, the technology might seem straight forward, but have you considered all other vectors? I once had a discussion about whether or not it makes sense to build our own worldwide labor time tracking solution. Again, it was not just the technology, but the cost (and risk) of becoming an expert at understanding all government and labor policies around the world, which constantly changes.

Myth #7 — Buying is not strategic for us

Proponents of this myth perhaps did not hear about the fast-follower strategy. Fast followers recognize the challenges of entering into a new market and/or technology: unknown customer reactions, cost of educating the market, unforeseen technology glitches, … So, fast followers wait on the sidelines until the new market/technology is sufficiently mature before entry. By building and integrating on others’ technologies, fast followers can further compress their product lifecycle and get to market even faster. Later on, as the value drivers for the new market become clear, the fast follower can decide to re-implement previously bought technologies by building their own.

So, here is a quick summary of different factors to consider when making build vs. buy decisions.

  • If your culture is not open to buying and you don’t have the leadership strength to manage the change, then this is a wrong time to buy. However, if the scope is limited, it could also be a precious learning process for your organization.
  • Focus on your core value drivers: what really matters to your business and your customers. Make sure your effort and energy is spent in these areas.
  • If the technology/product in question is not a strategic value to your customers or to your firm, ask yourself if it is worth developing the competency in-house.
  • Time-to-market for extending into new markets and customer segments is an important competitive advantage. In this case, it might make sense to buy first and then build second.
  • Consider if this product/technology is a one-time use, or a core building block for your product portfolio.
  • Quick prototypes (using off-the-shelf technologies) are invaluable to firms for test-driving new ideas. This quickly (and with low cost) enables the firm to understanding potential risks, opportunities and customer behaviors.
  • Consider how well the technology/product to be purchased would be integrated into your product line and to your value-chain (sales, customer support, marketing, …). You need to manage the complete value-chain to be successful.
  • Though on the surface buying a technology might reduce your development risks, it might increase risks along another dimension, such as integration and dependency management. Make sure you build these into your plans.

Finally, with apologies to The Clash

Should I build or should I buy now?
If I buy there will be trouble
An if I build it will be double
So come on and let me know
Should I build or should I buy?

Technorati Tags: , ,

‘Cause we’ve always done it this way

Tuesday, August 21st, 2007

To which I ask “if everybody before you has jumped off the bridge, would you follow?” Yup, we’ve always done it this way is one of my pet peeves. I believe there is a time and place for everything, and things/circumstances do change.

Organizational memory is a valuable asset for the firm. It is defined as shared data, information or knowledge of past experiences that are relevant to an organization’s present activities. As such, it lives in the collective memory of the employees and evolves with them. Improvement in the overall effectiveness and success of the organization is dependent on the quality of its memory and how well it learns from the past. Yet, organizations routinely “forget” what they have done in the past and why they have done it, which reminds me of the classic Thanksgiving turkey story:

A teenager was watching her mom carefully stuff and prepare the turkey for the oven. As part of the preparation, prior to putting the turkey into the oven, mom cut about 3″ from the tail of the bird. When the teenager asked why that was, mom simply said “I don’t know… Mom always did it this way. Why don’t you ask your grandmother?”. Later on that night at the dinner table, the teen queried grandma, to which she responded “Well you see… My oven was too small, so in order to fit my 20lb turkey, I always had to cut off about 3″ from the tail.”

Yup, things and circumstances usually do change… Alzheimer-like poor organizational memory usually results from a lack of leadership focus on learning from past success and failures, and where the organizational processes do not require employees to document and share organizational actions, outcomes, and to apply those learnings to new problems. The information overload that we experience daily certainly makes the problem more challenging to deal with. As the firm heavily relies on individuals to be the keeper of organizational experience, turnover, attrition and downsizing eventually erodes precious knowledge, learnings and insights. With that, effective organizational memory is compromised of three parts:

  1. Explicit knowledge, information, facts, policies or rules that are embodied within the culture;
  2. Tacit knowledge, insights, knowledge of the rationale, discussions, assumptions behind those explicit knowledge and information that is shared and understood by the organization;
  3. Application of this knowledge, recognition of the knowledge, its context and successful internalization, associations and utilization of the knowledge by the organization;

Basically, you need to be able to move from “we’ve always done it that way”, to be able to share why, how and other relevant context, to successfully recognize how those experiences might be relevant to a new problem or that the circumstances have changed and it’s time for an update.

Companies heavily rely on groupware tools (wikis, Microsoft Sharepoint, …) to capture and manage their organizational memory. Given that the organizational memory lives as part of the collective memory of the employees, you can see the challenges associated with managing a living organism. However, the real competitive advantage comes from the application of this knowledge within the appropriate context of the new problem that needs to be solved. So, unless the organization successfully fires on all three cylinders and builds a learning organization, it will not be effective at utilizing their collective knowledge for new ideas, inventions or innovations.

If you think your organization is suffering from (hopefully) a temporary case of amnesia, here are some suggestions to improve the overall effectiveness of your organization’s memory.

  • Formalize processes for creating and using organizational memory. This includes holding project postmortems where you capture the learnings, but also a specific action plan that would be applicable to the overall organization as well as next project. And, make it part of your project initiation phase to review prior postmortem reports.
  • Build a learning organization by insisting on learning from past success and failures. As with life, learning is multi-dimensional, it is individual and collective. So, be inclusive and encouraging in your learning process.
  • Make it easy for the organization to capture the knowledge by investing in tools to easily capture, catalog and organize knowledge and information being exchanged. However, focus on building a learning culture by putting in processes that requires connection with the rationale and assumptions of past decisions and learn from it in a way that would be applied to today’s problems.
  • Continuously expand on the organization’s memory and experience. New knowledge can be gained through customer surveys, tradeshows, hiring people with relevant experience, … You can utilize your vision, your core competencies and strategic objectives as a method for determining where you want to enhance your learnings.
  • Remember, people are fallible and our memories are flawed. As you remember and apply past learnings, make sure it is within the context of the new problems. Otherwise, you are dealing with apples vs. oranges.
  • As with anything you want to improve, focus on measuring your initiatives. This can be simply implemented as assessment surveys, utilization of knowledge management and collaboration tools and measures of your best practices in the organization.

So, next time you catch yourself arguing “we’ve always done it this way”, stop and think. Recognize that it just might be the right time to question the so called wisdom.

Technorati Tags: , ,

sildenafil uk only purchase oxycontin from online pharmacies soloft paxil prosac depression anxiety chemical sildenafil phentermine lowest prices phentermin buy phentermine cod trusted pharmacy catalog seroquel for treating depression fermenting ephedra soma online medicine without prescription soma soma san diego interpol herbal phentermine forum cheap phentermine free sh diet prednisone diet phentermine pills drug phentermine oxycontin for pain relief order cheap cost tadalafil online buy phentermine pills without doctor herbal phentermine resources relenza market share gsk phentermine 37 5 order medication beyond prozac international premier pharmacy effects of paxil sildenafil coronary sertraline online buy soma t shirts interaction between xanax and prozac buy tadalafil pay with check online cod mg phentermine mg phentermine basics buy u s a tadalafil online effect prozac side generic prozac cheap 2737 amerimedrx flonase renova viarga phentermine 30 mg buy cod phentermine phentermine diet buy phentermine sildenafil tablet 100 picture phentermine 37,5 paxil morning alcohol night ritalin for weight loss line pharmacy propecia discount pharmacy paxil what is the pill soma 58 electric jolts prozac paxil to prozac sertraline weight loss negative affects of prozac fluoxetine prozac prozac weekly cheapest soma online no prescription generic fast overnight phentermine overnight delivery for phentermine phentermine 37.5mg $79 online prescription paroxetine sildenafil viagra and the heart effects of mixing risperdal with zoloft phentermine hcl 37 mg tablets ortho pharmaceuticals renova soma muscle relaxor buy soma carisoprodol paxil class action suite taking phentermine with antidepressants lowest price phentermine without perscription weight loss after prednisone side effects soma car finance offers pcp phentermine hcl bulk 100 powder cheap online prozac does prednisone cause hair loss sildenafil hemodynamics super 1 buy rohypnol without prescription cheap paroxetine buy online paxil and alcohol's effects wellbutrin clinical comparison to prozac soma pill information getting provigil without a prescription ionamin phentermine resin complex drug 3.37 30 mg phentermine toxic levels of prozac 160 mg of prozac eon lab liability phentermine product headaches and prozac nexium verses prilosec adipex loss phentermine weight acne from propecia drugs alcohol and steroids prednisone apnea phentermine ship uk who soma club san diego purchase prozac prednisone dosage canine arthritis diabetes tadalafil 30 mg phentermine hcl phentermine uk shipping online where to purchase phentermine online kamagra sildenafil site viagra order tadalafil 200 online car pcp finance prednisone for hair growth order paxil cr online synthroid and antidepressant metabolism prevacid brand pharmacy canadian hydrocodone licensed prescription meds prednisone india buying soma on-line low cost propecia diet no phentermine pill prescription prescription and propecia sertraline hcl generic zoloft wellbutrin xl and paxil phentermine no rx overnight pimozide and prozac 5 indian sildenafil phentermine and diet phentermine us pharmacy no prescription phentermine online cheap diet pills does prozac help you lose weight buy phentermine lowest price limited amount order tadalafil 50 online buy cod diet phentermine pill phentermine using mastercard soma muscle relaxer made by softtabs money order online justice seekers prozac pcp addiction treatment man s health phentermine diet pill paxil cr not for sale finance soma 99 free phentermine shipping drug abuse of pcp drug interactions for prozac fastest sildenafil delivery alcohol interaction prozac sildenafil gastroparesis remeron augmented with ssri prozac will prozac affect my pregnancy potatoes not prozac hardcover glenmullen prozac backlash overcoming phentermine ephedrine prednisone deltasone no prescription accepted cod phentermine 2004 relenza market share dropped soma online cheap free shipping adipex diet discount phentermine pill softtabs with no prescription online phentermine adipex overnight buying soma without a prescription accutane guild prempro legal drug allergy to generic ritalin depression caused by prozac order prilosec online from dreampharmaceuticals sertraline versus zoloft herbal phentermine 32 phentermine brand name fastin buy tadalafil 60 online longterm effect of prozac overdose social anxiety relief paxil hairloss baldness propecia adipex ionamin online phentermine qoclick forum for prozac users generic propecia finasteride viagra propecia picture pill soma phentermine overnight delivery us licensed pharmacies low price tadalafil online brain trauma and prozac tadalafil online $114 coupons for paxil cr priscription phentermine 37.5mg current information 1 buy mg propecia paxil cr and 2006 annual sales meridia sibutramine and xenical orlistat diet prescription phentermine diabetes diet prescription 5 citrato de sildenafil depression phentermine order tadalafil from usa online accepts cod phentermine kathy willits prozac serotonin prozac sertraline night sweats 6 finasteride proscar propecia order softtabs with check online tadalafil success rate for erectile dysfunction online pharmacy retin paxil for menopause crying 6hair loss baldness propecia buy cheap ritalin buy phentermine cheap phentermine can usage of prevacid cause hairloss soma compound overdose symptoms soma 350mg 150 pills generic tadalafil message board order tadalafil 270 online nursing process prozac phentermine online cheap phentermine buy phentermine order us softtabs online phentermine hcl prescription diet phentermine side effects trusted pharmacy catalog prednisone medication which cat ate prozac fluoxetine paroxetine clomipramine sildenafil every 3 hours soft tablet tadalafil hci sertraline zoloft phentermine prices synthroid night sweats calm prozac ssri drug names zoltan prozac nexium prilocec prevacid purchase tadalafil compare pravachol to lipitor cholestrol drugs sildenafil cream discount buy prilosec online order softtabs 50 online synthroid dye allergy cheap diet phentermine pill can you take tylenol and prozac order plavix 75 mg soma district san francisco galleries cod pay soma dysfunction erectile prozac paxil paroxetine dosage premature ejaculatoin tadalafil medication cod phentermine no rx needed weight loss with phentermine phentermine weight loss shiped buy cheap phentermine in mo paxil cr drug sildenafil vega sleep soma sildenafil intravenous 1.0mg ml depression help seroquel seroquel and zoloft interaction global pharmacy phentermine sideaffects of prozac buy carisoprodol soma sildenafil medlineplus info on prozac 150 soma without prescription trazadone increase prozac effect prednisone for cat no prescription hydroxycut prozac interactions find buy tadalafil cialis at ebay overmedication with prozac 30mg phentermine from canada seroquel and zoloft interactions chemical structure of prozac effects soma taking prozac and lexapro combination soma records 1137 sale price zenegra how sildenafil works zoloft instead of prozac 5 sildenafil in 24 hours tappering off paxil to zoloft phentermine blue 30 mg premarin and female hair loss phentermine average weight loss ivf premarin wilmington finance paxil where can i buy cheap phentermine hair loss phentermine elavil and prozac depression from prednisone pcp treatment centers in nj no effect from prozac xenical prevacid aldara nasacort aq california home loan mortgage retin wellbutrin and prozac phentermine diet pill buy duramine paxil cr medicine wellbutrin pravachol actos alphagan trade name pioglitazone bosentan and sildenafil 7 proscar vs propecia filing income tax buy soma order propecia now prevacid over the counter marelna aura soma weight loss drug propecia sildenafil citrate process ingrediants cherry frui christina ricci prozac the anxiety community treatment medication paxil oxycontin rehab california phentermine accept cod phentermine caps 30 mg paxil pill pravachol nexium actos phentermine tamiflu prescription drug synthroid aura soma quintessence set buying phentermine using mastercard no rx phentermine 30mg 90 120 buy cheapest price tadalafil online soma on sale help with the prescription drug soma online tadalafil remeron insomnia taking prozac with wellbutrin natual remedies instead of taking prozac drug prednisone prescription buy cheap soma cod soma phone oklahoma purchase sertraline pharmacy bbc panorama prozac taking zoloft and paxil coupons prevacid nexium cheap 60mg prozac phentermine diet phentermine purchase phentermine purchase famotidine 20mg tablet pepcid co q-10 and prozac net doctor propecia online prednisone no prescription oxycontin's tylenol content paxil paxil cr school report pcp phoenix myth of soma server best prices phentermine online pharmacy optimum propecia dosage cheap phentermine free shipping no prescription wellbutrin aciphex phentermine nasonex altace 5 sildenafil tablets synthroid and anxiety attacks soma laser hair removal in houston sertraline allergies plato not prozac reviews drug effects side synthroid thyroid soma dealing with oxycontin withdrawals phentermine prozac prescription order propecia hairloss propecia research compare cilift to prozac paxil and eating disorders lilly prozac dogs is prozac for me purchase prozac online treating adhd with prozac wellbutrin prozac combination crushing and snorting soma muscle relaxer keyword prozac and teenager board compare pharmacy prices singulair order tadalafil free shipping online phentermine 37.5mg web board sildenafil citrates synthroid and adrenal fatigue paxil zoloft knee pain is prednisone used for back pain pella et prozac ritalin perceived fatigue exercse lamictal proscribed with prozac for depression seroquel for depression tadalafil soft tabs buy phentermine phentermine free shipping 37 5 cheap phentermine pravachol for diabetes phentermine overnight no rx singulair prescription drugs phentermine 37 5 physician buy seroquel 25 mg no prescription prednisone hair loss umaxppc car leasing and pcp sertraline zoloft for dogs dreampharmaceuticals from online order pravachol treatment of oxycontin addiction in canada sildenafil without prescription phentermine 37 5mg web board psychiatrist not monitoring teenagers on prozac compare tadalafil online soma sleep phentermine overnighted 37.5mg $90 barr prozac lilly stock sildenafil viagra drug interaction provigil and alprazolam diet phentermine pill effexor provigil suboxone order softtabs 90 online celexa versus prozac overnight shipping phentermine without a prescription 5 sildenafil research premarin stimulate lining ivf women s health intuitive premarin arm cheap ranitidine pharmacy soma online sales drug test for sibutramine meridia flomax prozac cheap phentermine diet pill buy ritalin online without prescription melange de xenadrine et sibutramine ephedra with phentermine zoloft sertraline tablets depression seasonal paxil marijuana and prozac prednisone cluster headache sildenafil tablet 6 propecia acne lowest price tadalafil online paxil and neonatal depression pravachol weight loss mixing prozac and wellbutran bi-polar and prozac buspar forum buspar compare paxil zoloft effects of prozac on stool phentermine medlineplus drug information phentermine tamiflu online pharmacy buy prevacid online phentermine overnight phentermine buying tadalafil online prescription diet pills phentermine pied piper of prozac aura soma friedberg price propecia best genric sildenafil in tijuana soma san diego venue cheapest 30 mg phentermine online combining prozac and effexor no prednisone prescription 2737 allegra amerimedrx prevacid propecia online steroids pharmacy paxil viagra florida in overnight phentermine shipped cns effects of soma difference between paxil and paroxetine singulair flomax actos vaniqa equine long term prednisone health insurance pay for propecia dry mouth and synthroid order tadalafil mail to online paxil zoloft and birth defects phentermine paid cod what is the history of prozac comparing prozac effexor zoloft phentermine cod ordering soma tablets pcp car finance specialists uk sildenafil citrate from india diet drug phentermine pill prescription ejaculation premature prozac prevacid meltable tablets for children wellbutrin xl versus prozac paxil plus alcohol pravachol joint pain phentermine pay cod sildenafil no prescription needed soma 2b cod plendil can prozac cause depression to worsen soma cafe phoenix synthroid and weight loss merck propecia rebate japan prozac viagra propecia pain relief headache estate real soma ky phentermine shipped cash on delivery shipping of phentermine itchy rash with fatigue and propecia soma shelf life buy synthroid online no prescription 150 doctor mcg online synthroid paxil foul stools flatulence diarrhea depression treatment prozac business prozac emphysema prednisone expected weight loss with phentermine over the counter equivalent of prednisone phentermine weight loss stories online pharmacy phentermine without prescription meridia online description chemistry ingredients sibutramine buy phentermine online com buy phentermine online uk shipping can you snort prozac sdvice getting off prozac buy tadalafil prescription medication by cod phentermine soma pill pictures melatonin prozac phentermine buy cod rash side effects of paxil paxil drug interactions cough prednisone affecting birth control pills zenegra indian sildenafil lyrics prozac made me stay cheap tadalafil buy discount tadalafil online finasteride or propecia or proscar welbutrin and prozac over the counter prednisone like drugs buy cheap domain phentermine phentermine cod fedex phentermine brave new world soma quotes diabetes caused by prednisone usage insomnia seroquel synthroid side effects diet paxil side effects lack of motivation phentermine guaranteed overnight delivery usa only phentermine and zoloft discount sertraline zoloft fluoxetine prozac pills mixing alcohol and prozac mudvayne prozac paxil and wellbutrin together remeron prozac combination sildenafil tatse like mint phentermine overnight cod accepted sildenafil zenegra wellbutrin pravachol metformin citrate over sea sildenafil anafranil prozac discount canadian drugs prevacid 30 mg soma rx online pharmacy soma information about buy cheap phentermine today canadian pharmacy seroquel sildenafil citrate prescription order prozac online 30 mg phentermine no prescription can prozac cause stomach problems cheap refill on phentermine 30 mg nexium prilosec interactions pepcid ac drug soma pharmacist and omaha clinical depression prozac 4.01 buy cheap n phentermine prednisone no prescription cod drug paxil buy tadalafil by mail online somas drug phentermine overnight to california paxil wellbutrin combination online pharmacy for phentermine sildenafil citrateoverseas phentermine 37 5 canada seroquel weight loss and gain prednisone forte body weight loss suits renova causes for hair loss propecia cho seung-hui prozac weekly prozac vanilla ice prozac softtabs prescription pill online synthroid causing depression sildenafil plasma dosing premarin in the treatment of depression order softtabs with check cheap propecia online natural and prozac buy softtabs cyber pharmacy paxil cr and gi tadalafil patent information mixing alcohol with paxil ambien remeron no prescription overnight ship 5 sildenafil gastroparesis phentermine overnight fedex 7 effectiveness propecia proscar discount propecia propecia side sildenafil efectos please help cant loose prozac weight generic sildenafil viagra drug interactions with welchol and prozac herb equal to prozac phentermine for weightloss tadalafil erectile dysfunction tadalafil sildenafil sue paxil cr phenergan tablets canadian online pharmacy phentermine hair loss drugs propecia metadate and prozac buy premarin tablets cyara sildenafil missed dose of prozac paxil vs wellbutrin dealing with depression names for prozac prednisone hair loss in dogs zoloft vs seroquel which is better rogaine or propecia bulimia prozac soma prescription oxycontin and weight loss oxycontin insomnia sildenafil citrate lozenge pills called soma hating prozac sildenafil vision problems buy steroids without prescription carol lundrum aura soma buy phentermine online discount cheap pharmacy prilosec weight loss hydrochloride phentermine zoloft or paxil somas drugs ritalin and drug abuse sildenafil overdose switching from paxil to wellbutrin online weight loss clinic phentermine buy phentermine online no prescription required nexium prilosec prevacid paxil cr stopping losing weight synthroid cytomel 5 sildenafil women phentermine no rx overnight fedex cod phentermine cod 32 zoloft sertraline hcl pfizer patent order phentermine on line changing form prozac foreign drugs equivalent to phentermine buy discount paxil prednisone type 1 diabetes soma financial services what type of drug is propecia phentermine online pharmacy's phentermine for sale in us prevacid causing depression 60 mg prozac pcp car loans specialists buy cheapest cost softtabs online compare paxil and zoloft relenza online pharmacy does prednisone make you tired paxil and drinking alcohol 5 mg dysfunction erectile sildenafil phentermine overnight c o d zyprexa prozac combination therapy aura soma therapy zoloft veruse prozac effexor and prozac phentermine overnight no subscription buy cd cheap phentermine site loss review sibutramine weight paxil cr ocd paxil calss action lawsuit weightloss clinics phentermine prednisone and the birth control pill can you take prozac with ritalin phoenix soma game order tadalafil prescribes online tadalafil interaction with alcohol adderal prozac combination where to buy cheap phentermine phentermine 30mg without perscription oxycontin pain relief new fda dog prozac buy online phentermine forzest tadalafil tablets paxil cr online